This post is a corollary?to my previous post on character admissions. I?ve seen the following issue many times but most recently in DreamWorks? Puss in Boots. It is a minor complaint in this particular film so if you haven?t seen it yet, do so before reading on. I don?t want to spoil your enjoyment of an excellent film because there are spoilers below.
Humpty and Puss? grew up together as friends. They were both mischievous in their younger years (pictured above) but Puss had an opportunity to turn his life around. Humpty later tricks Puss into helping him with one last job ? robbing the local bank.?When?Puss discovers the deception, he whispers in his friend?s hearing:
?You tricked me.?
True to life, if you were tricked into committing a crime, the first thing out of your mouth would probably also be, ?You tricked me!??The problem is, that is the last time Puss ever utters those words.
Any normal person wrongly accused of a crime would repeat this truth to everyone they met ? especially the authorities ? until they listened.?Characters should speak the truth.?
Yet Puss says this only once and only in the hearing of the one who betrayed him who already knew it. He never mentions it again. Not when confronted with the local authorities and not in front of his mother. Both of which happen multiple times.
Worse yet, at the end of the film Puss admits being guilty for a crime he didn?t commit rather than utter those three simple words. Puss didn?t rob the bank. Humpty did and it was Humpty who got Puss to help under false pretenses.
Speaking precisely, the flaw being identified is a form of misunderstanding that occurs when a character?fails?to express?their proper motivation. Puss being misunderstood is required for the plot of the film. Puss in Boots is fabulous otherwise. It is well-written and Humpty?s dialogue is some of the best I?ve ever experienced. DreamWorks really shines with their dialogue and especially their voicework.
The flaw is actually much more prominent in another genre of film: Romantic Comedies. I can?t remember a recent romcom that didn?t include this flaw and I confess I?ve quit watching them like so many movie goers. Misunderstandings are fine premises as stories go. They are certainly common enough and can be done correctly, but misunderstandings?in real life are almost never based on one character in jeopardy?failing to state the obvious truth when given the opportunity. Yet this?limp-dish-rag variety of misunderstanding has become a staple of the romcom.
Bottom Line: Don?t write characters this way. Don?t even use such a motivation as a placeholder in your development process. This problem ? the natural expression of a character?s motivation ? is avoidable simply by removing the ability for the character to express it. So,?suppress the truth. Put a gag in that character?s mouth for that scene, either physically or metaphorically. Write in a boisterous character that won?t let the truth be heard. Better yet, tie this boisterous character into the plot by giving them something to lose if the truth got out. Give?them the motivation to prevent the truth coming out even if it is as simple as the guard in Puss in Boots swearing to bring him in if it?s the last thing he ever does.
Puss has no gag and nothing to lose by speaking the truth. In fact he has everything to gain and since Humpty has presumable already paid for his crime, nothing he says will harm his former friend. All of which is why this bit of Puss? character falls flat. Admittedly, DreamWorks attempted to plug this hole in the final scene with a plea by Puss? mother to not fight the guards before he had an opportunity to speak. But in all honesty he?d already had that opportunity multiple times and didn?t take any of them.
Remember, speak the truth or?suppress it. Those are the only two acceptable options.
If you want to know more of the ills applicable to the romcom, as well as where they shine, I invite you to visit the Living the Romantic Comedy blog by Billy Mernit. If you haven?t seen Puss in Boots and are reading this, then do yourself a favor and cue up the movie on Netflix. Despite this flaw, it?s a very fun family-friendly movie with lessons about friendship, loyalty, and redemption.
35.684013 -82.009275
Like this:
Be the first to like this.
Victoria Soto nbc sports morgan freeman Survivor Philippines westboro baptist church Fashion Island shooting Victor Cruz
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.